Mon–Fri, 8am–5pm MT
Get a free SEO audit

12 questions to ask before you hire an SEO agency

Choosing an agency

Print this list, take it into every sales call, and compare the answers. Good agencies welcome these questions.

By the Balrin AEO & SEO team · Published

The fastest way to judge an SEO agency is to ask direct questions and listen carefully. Here are the twelve we would ask, with what a good answer sounds like. Feel free to ask us every one of them.

Questions about the work

1. What will you do in the first 90 days?

A good answer is specific: an audit, fixes to your Business Profile and listings, the pages they will write or improve, and how they will measure progress. A vague answer like "optimize your site" is a warning sign.

2. Who will actually do the work?

Ask whether the work is done in-house or outsourced, and who your main contact will be. You should be able to talk to someone who knows your account.

3. How do you build links?

Good answers mention earning links from real, relevant sites: local associations, suppliers, news and useful content. Walk away from anyone selling large numbers of cheap links.

4. How do you handle AI search?

AI Overviews, ChatGPT and Perplexity now answer many searches. A current agency should explain how it helps you show up in those answers, not just in the blue links.

Questions about results

5. How will you measure success?

The best answers talk about calls, form leads, booked jobs and revenue, not only rankings and traffic.

6. What will the monthly report show?

Ask to see a sample report. It should be readable in five minutes and explain what was done, what changed and what comes next.

7. What results can you show from businesses like mine?

Ask for case studies and references you can contact. Real results with permission beat logos on a slide.

8. Do you guarantee rankings?

The right answer is no. Nobody controls Google's results. Agencies that guarantee positions are guessing or using tactics that put your site at risk.

Want us to check this for you?

The free SEO audit looks at your site, your Google Business Profile and how AI assistants describe your business.

Get a free SEO audit

Questions about the relationship

9. How long is the contract?

Month to month or short terms are best for you. Long lock-ins protect the agency.

10. Who owns the website, content and accounts?

You should. Your site, Google Business Profile, Search Console, Analytics and every page written for you should stay in your name.

11. What happens if I cancel?

You should keep everything, with no penalty beyond the notice period.

12. What do you need from me?

Good SEO needs some of your time: access to accounts, answers about your services and help asking customers for reviews. An agency that needs nothing from you is probably not doing much.

Compare the answers

After a few calls, the differences will be obvious. Choose the agency that answered plainly, showed real proof and offered fair terms. For the bigger picture, see how to choose an SEO agency.

Balrin AEO & SEO is an SEO and AI search company serving businesses across Wyoming, with 18 years of SEO experience. We write these guides from the work we do for clients every month. About us · How we work

Keep reading

Related articles

Find out where you rank today

The free audit covers your site, your Google Business Profile and how AI assistants describe you.

Get a free SEO audit
Call us Free SEO audit